Habits

Self-discipline

Self-discipline is doing what you decided to do when something easier is on offer. Disciplined people do not spend their days fighting temptation. They set up their day so there is less to fight. This page counts it as a weekly number: the hours kept out of the hours you promised yourself.

Last updated

Reviewed by Mohammed Raqeeb

Share this page

The definition

What is self-discipline? Meaning and definition.

Self-discipline means acting for what you want later when something easier is on offer right now. You want two things at once, a small one now and a bigger one later, and you act for the bigger one.

Researchers mostly call it self-control. On this page, self-discipline and self-control mean the same thing.

The definition says nothing about gritting your teeth. That matters, because the studies further down this page found that people with a lot of self-control are not the ones fighting temptation all day.

How to build it

How to build self-discipline, in five moves.

Building self-discipline is mostly a matter of making promises that are small, exact and easy to start. Five moves do that.

  1. Make the promise in hours, with a time and a place. You cannot tell whether you kept a promise to “be more disciplined.” You can tell, at the end of the evening, whether you kept “half an hour of reading after dinner, at the kitchen table.”
  2. Write it as an if-then plan. An if-then plan ties the action to a moment in the day. For example: “if the dinner plates are cleared, then I sit down and open the book.” A review that combined 94 tests found that plans like this help people reach their goals (Gollwitzer and Sheeran, 2006).
  3. Remove the temptation before the hour starts. Put the phone in another room before you sit down, so there is nothing to resist. The next section shows why this works better than trying hard.
  4. Repeat it until you do it without much thought. In a study of people building a new daily habit, the middle person took 66 days to do it without much thought. Some took 18 days, and some took up to 254 (Lally and colleagues, 2010). Missing a single day made no real difference. The guide to habit formation covers this step. Why a little every day beats one big push is on the power of consistency.
  5. Promise less than you think you can do. People tend to guess low on how long their own tasks will take, even when they know similar tasks ran late before (Buehler, Griffin and Peetz, 2010). A small promise kept in full gives you a number to build on.

The surprise

Disciplined people arrange their day. They do not resist harder.

Disciplined people are usually pictured as people who are good at saying no to temptation. Research on ordinary days found something different.

One study followed people’s goals for a semester, with short questions through the day (Milyavskaya and Inzlicht, 2017). Whether a goal was reached depended on how many temptations a person met, not on how hard they resisted them. Trying hard to resist made no difference.

So where does the advantage of disciplined people come from? A set of 6 studies with 2,274 people points to habits (Galla and Duckworth, 2015). People with more self-control had stronger habits for studying, exercise, healthy snacks and regular sleep. Those habits, more than effort, linked their self-control to good results.

Put together, the studies describe discipline as arranging the day more than resisting it: a fixed time, a fixed place, and the tempting thing out of reach.

Why it matters

Why is self-discipline important?

Self-discipline goes with doing well at school, more than raw intelligence does. In a study of 164 eighth graders, self-discipline measured in the fall explained more than twice as much of the difference in final grades as IQ did (Duckworth and Seligman, 2005).

The same students with more self-discipline also spent more hours on homework and fewer in front of the television. Those are hours you can count in a day, which is what the rest of this page does.

Try it

Promised versus kept: count your week.

To count discipline, divide the time you kept by the time you promised. The result is a share. The counter starts filled in with one made-up week: half an hour of reading promised every evening, with one evening missed when work ran late. Change each day to your own promise and what you kept, or start blank.

Your week, day by day

Pick a day, enter the time you promised, then the time you kept.

Example person
Promised Kept

Wednesday

Promised
30m
Kept
0h

Kept this week

88%

3h 5m kept out of 3h 30m promised.

80%

You kept 80% or more of the time you promised, which is the line this page uses for a promise that is holding. Keep the same promise next week and see if it holds again.

Days kept in full

4 of 7

Promised time missed

40m

Added up day by day, so extra time on one day does not cancel a missed day.

This week I kept 3h 5m of the 3h 30m I promised myself: 88%.

These are your own counts from memory, so they are estimates. Nothing you enter leaves this page.

The share can pass a hundred percent when you do more than you promised. Extra time on Saturday does not undo a missed Wednesday, though, so the counter also shows the days kept in full. To keep the count on paper, the habit tracker template has a row for each day.

The test

How you know it is working.

The test

The hours you kept come to 80% or more of the hours you promised

every week, for four weeks in a row.

A good way to run this test counts the kept hours from what you already write or say about your day, so the count does not depend on starting a timer at the very moment you are tempted to skip. Most journaling apps stop at how the day felt. A streak or a mood tells you whether you showed up, but not how much of the promised time you really gave.

One app built for this is Think in Numbers, a smart journaling app with time tracking built in.

You write or say your day in your own words, as it happens or all at once. The app reads what you wrote and counts the hours that went to each part of it: the hours your promise got, what took their place, your phone, and the time you never mentioned (shown as unaccounted). Then it shows those hours over days and weeks. A target for the week is checked against your real hours. Add the promise as a habit, such as 30 minutes of reading, and the app ticks it off when the hours you wrote reach it, with a streak and a reminder.

1. You write your day

2. It counts the hours

  • Reading0m
  • Work0m
  • Sleep0m
  • Unaccounted24h

3. It shows your week

S
M
T
W
T
F
S

Reading this week: 0m

On 6 of 7 days. The gap is the day without it.

An example day and week.

Write my first day

For iPhone and Android. Try it on your own day before you pay.

The line of 80% in this test is our own choice, not a research finding. It is below a hundred percent because every real month has a day when work runs late and the promise is missed. A share that stays low tells you something about the promise, not about you: make it smaller, move it to a steadier time, or take the temptation out of the room.

Sources

Where the numbers come from.

Every research figure on this page links to one of these sources. Where only the abstract of a paper was open to read, the page reports only what the abstract states.

  1. Gollwitzer, P. M. and Sheeran, P. (2006). Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 38, 69 to 119.
  2. Lally, P., van Jaarsveld, C. H. M., Potts, H. W. W. and Wardle, J. (2010). How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real world. European Journal of Social Psychology, 40(6), 998 to 1009.
  3. Buehler, R., Griffin, D. and Peetz, J. (2010). The planning fallacy: cognitive, motivational, and social origins. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 43, 1 to 62.
  4. Milyavskaya, M. and Inzlicht, M. (2017). What's so great about self-control? Examining the importance of effortful self-control and temptation in predicting real-life depletion and goal attainment. Social Psychological and Personality Science, 8(6), 603 to 611.
  5. Galla, B. M. and Duckworth, A. L. (2015). More than resisting temptation: Beneficial habits mediate the relationship between self-control and positive life outcomes. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 109(3), 508 to 525.
  6. Duckworth, A. L. and Seligman, M. E. P. (2005). Self-discipline outdoes IQ in predicting academic performance of adolescents. Psychological Science, 16(12), 939 to 944.

Found this useful? Pass it on.

Questions

Questions people ask.

Self-control vs self-discipline: what is the difference?

In research the two words mean the same thing. Psychologists mostly write self-control. Self-discipline is the everyday word for acting on what you decided when something easier is on offer.

How long does it take to build self-discipline?

No study has timed self-discipline as a whole, but one timed how long a habit takes to form. For the middle person in that study, a new daily action took 66 days to happen without much thought, and people ranged from 18 to 254 days. Expect weeks of kept promises before the promise stops feeling like effort.

How do I improve my self-discipline?

Start with one promise that is small and exact: an amount in hours, with a time and a place. Write it as an if-then plan, remove the temptation before the hour starts, and repeat the action until you do it without much thought. Then, each week, count the hours you kept against the hours you promised.

What should I do when I miss a day?

Keep the promise the next day. In the habit study by Lally and colleagues, missing a single day made no real difference to how the habit formed. Count the miss in your week honestly, look at what took the time, and make the same promise for tomorrow.

How do I measure my self-discipline?

Divide the hours you kept by the hours you promised, once a week. A promise is holding when that share stays at 80% or more. If it stays lower, the promise is likely too large for the week you really have, so make it smaller and keep all of it.

Try it on my day.

Write today down in your own words, and see where the hours went.

Write my first day

For iPhone and Android. Try it on your own day before you pay.